Assessing the Benefits and Drawbacks of Downsizing Your House When in Debt: A Comprehensive Guide

The question of How to Decide if Downsizing Your Home When You’re in Debt Is Worth It is one that has become increasingly pertinent in these financially challenging times. With the COVID-19 pandemic triggering an unprecedented economic downturn, many individuals are considering downsizing to alleviate their financial burdens. However, it’s crucial to understand that this is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and careful evaluation is necessary before making such a significant decision.

Understanding the New Normal: Debt as a Constant Companion

In the past couple of decades, low-interest rates have normalized the concept of living in debt for many people. From groceries and vacations to mortgages and personal loans, credit has become an inseparable part of our lives. However, viewing debt as a normal part of life can lead us into a financial trap that’s hard to escape.

The COVID-19 pandemic has shifted our spending habits, but credit usage has rebounded to almost pre-pandemic levels. This trend has led economists to predict a subsequent economic and insolvency crisis following the health crisis.

While we navigate these troubled waters, interest rates are expected to remain low. This presents an opportunity to pay off debt before interest rates rise to their normal levels. However, this path might require making some tough decisions to balance your budget.

Comparing Housing Costs vs. Downsizing in Debt

Evaluating Your Housing-Related Expenditure: Are You House Poor?

Overcommitting to any single type of expense can lead to a financial crunch. Housing-related costs such as mortgage, utilities, and property taxes are some of the most significant expenses for most families. When we overspend on housing-related expenses, we risk becoming “house poor,” meaning that the high costs of homeownership leave us with insufficient funds for other necessary expenses.

However, the decision to downsize to free up cash and reduce debt is not always clear-cut. It’s crucial to understand the implications and costs associated with downsizing before making this decision.

The Hidden Expenses of Downsizing

Choosing to downsize is not a decision to be taken lightly. The process involves selling your current house, finding a new one, moving, and adjusting to your new surroundings. These steps come with their own set of costs, making downsizing a long-term strategy rather than a quick fix.

The Costs of Buying and Selling Property

When buying a new property, it’s important to account for expenses such as closing costs, legal fees, land transfer taxes, real estate fees, and GST on fees. It’s advisable to budget an additional 5% of your purchase price, apart from the down payment, for these costs.

If you’re buying a brand-new property, you’ll also need to pay GST/HST, which is generally due at completion. Although there are rebates available, they are typically claimed after the payment, meaning you’ll have to bear the full cost upfront.

Down Payment and Mortgage Loan Insurance

If you don’t have a 20% down payment available from your savings or your current home’s equity, you’ll need to pay mortgage loan insurance. This cost depends on your mortgage amount. For instance, a 10% down payment would add a 3.10% fee onto your mortgage amount.

Closing Costs

When selling your home, you need to account for real estate fees, which typically range between 2% – 6% of your sale price. Additional expenses may include repairs, staging costs, landscaping for curb appeal, home inspections, appraisals, and surveys.

Mortgage Costs Between Renewal Dates

If you’re in the middle of your mortgage term and considering downsizing, it’s crucial to understand your lender’s terms and conditions to avoid any potential interest penalties.

Unforeseen Expenses

Moving involves many unexpected costs, such as packing supplies, time off work, painting and other home improvement tasks, movers, cleaners, utility deposits, and mail forwarding fees. It’s essential to factor in these costs when considering downsizing.


Assessing the Root of Your Financial Woes

While downsizing can save you money, it’s not a guaranteed solution to your debt problems. Therefore, it’s crucial to understand the root cause of your financial troubles before deciding to downsize. Ask yourself:


  • What expenses are keeping me in debt?
  • Is my income stable?
  • Can I reduce my bills by at least 10%?
  • Are all members of my household contributing to income and controlling spending?
  • Are my debt troubles a one-off incident or a long-term problem?


To answer these questions, use a budgeting spreadsheet to understand your spendings and potential areas of savings.

Revealing the True Picture: A Detailed Budget Analysis

By conducting a thorough review of your spending, you might find that cutting costs on other expenses could allow you to afford your current housing costs. Maybe your love for takeout meals, shopping sprees, or indulging your kids is what’s driving you into debt. Finding ways to cut these discretionary expenses could help you navigate these challenging times.

Is Your Debt a Product of the Pandemic or a Long-Term Issue?

Another critical consideration is whether your current financial troubles are a one-time situation due to the pandemic or a long-standing issue. If it’s the latter, downsizing might not be the most effective solution.

Downsizing: Is It Worth It?

After considering all the costs associated with downsizing, you might find that you need to downsize significantly to achieve any financial benefits. It’s crucial to explore all your options for managing your debt and keeping your family financially healthy during these challenging times.

There’s plenty of support available, from industry professionals to non-profit credit counselling organizations. They can help you determine whether it’s in your best interest to keep your current home or downsize.

In conclusion, understanding How to Decide If Downsizing Your Home When You’re in Debt Is Worth It is a nuanced process. It involves careful consideration of your spending habits, income stability, and future financial projections. With the right guidance, you can make an informed decision that’s best for you and your family.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.