Can You Include a Car Loan in a Consumer Proposal?

Navigating Car Loans in Consumer Proposals: A Comprehensive Guide

Overwhelming debt can be a significant burden, leading individuals to explore various debt relief options, such as consumer proposals. However, when it comes to car loans, the process can be more intricate. This article will delve into the intricacies of handling car loans within the context of a consumer proposal, providing a comprehensive understanding of the subject matter.

Can You Include a Car Loan in a Consumer ProposalThe Fundamentals: Secured vs. Unsecured Debts

To grasp the treatment of car loans in consumer proposals, it’s crucial to understand the distinction between secured and unsecured debts. Unsecured debts, such as credit card balances, lines of credit, and certain student loans, are not backed by collateral. Conversely, secured debts like car loans are tied to an asset – in this case, the vehicle itself – which serves as collateral for the lender.

Car Loans and Consumer Proposals: The General Rule

In general, car loans cannot be included in a consumer proposal unless the borrower is willing to surrender the vehicle to the secured creditor (the lender). This is because a consumer proposal is designed to address unsecured debts, allowing individuals to repay a portion of their outstanding balances over a fixed period, typically five years.

The Exception: Negative Equity and Loan Shortfalls

While car loans are typically excluded from consumer proposals, there is an exception. If a lender repossesses a vehicle due to missed payments and sells it at a loss, the remaining balance becomes an unsecured debt. This situation often arises when the vehicle’s value depreciates rapidly, leaving the borrower with negative equity or an “underwater” or “upside-down” car loan.

In such cases, the borrower can legally include the unsecured portion of the loan (the shortfall) in their consumer proposal, along with other unsecured debts.

The Benefits of a Consumer Proposal for Car Loan Management

Although a consumer proposal does not absolve borrowers from their car loan obligations, it can provide significant relief in managing these payments. By reducing the burden of unsecured debts, individuals may have more disposable income available to allocate towards their car loan payments, minimizing the risk of missed payments and potential repossession.

Moreover, a consumer proposal requires fixed monthly payments to unsecured creditors over a five-year period, without the need to surrender any assets, including the vehicle.

Obtaining a New Car Loan During a Consumer Proposal

It is possible to secure a new car loan while enrolled in a consumer proposal, albeit with stricter qualification requirements and potentially higher interest rates. Lenders may view individuals with active consumer proposals as higher-risk borrowers, leading to more stringent credit evaluations and the potential need for a co-signer or a higher down payment.

However, some specialized auto financing companies cater to individuals enrolled in or who have completed consumer proposals, offering more flexible lending criteria and potentially more favorable interest rates.

Exploring Alternatives to Defaulting on a Car Loan

If maintaining car loan payments becomes challenging, several alternatives exist to avoid defaulting and potential repossession. These options include:

Refinancing or Renegotiating Loan Terms

Borrowers can approach their lender to explore the possibility of refinancing the loan at a more favorable rate or renegotiating the payment plan. However, success in securing better terms may depend on the borrower’s current credit standing and the lender’s willingness to accommodate such requests.

Transferring the Loan to Another Individual

In some cases, lenders may allow borrowers to transfer their car loan to a friend or family member with a stronger credit profile and reliable income. However, not all lenders permit this option, and those that do will likely impose stringent requirements on the new borrower.

Selling or Trading In the Vehicle

Selling the vehicle and using the proceeds to pay off the remaining loan balance can be an effective solution for those unable to sustain car loan payments. Alternatively, individuals who require a vehicle can explore trading in their current one for a more affordable option, using the trade-in value to offset the outstanding loan balance and potentially securing a new car with a lower monthly payment.

Voluntary Repossession

In circumstances where all other options have been exhausted, voluntary repossession may be the most viable solution, albeit with significant credit implications. It’s crucial to initiate this process before filing a consumer proposal, as this allows borrowers to legally include any remaining loan shortfall as an unsecured debt in their proposal.

Consulting with Licensed Insolvency Trustees

For individuals considering a consumer proposal and grappling with car loan obligations, consulting with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) is highly recommended. LITs can provide valuable guidance on the potential impact of a consumer proposal on car loans, help determine the amount of debt that can be eliminated, and assess the overall feasibility of this debt relief option.

By working with an experienced LIT, individuals can gain a comprehensive understanding of their financial situation and make informed decisions regarding their car loan and other debts.

Conclusion: Navigating Car Loans in Consumer Proposals

Managing car loans within the context of a consumer proposal requires a thorough understanding of the legal and financial implications involved. While car loans are generally excluded from consumer proposals, there are exceptions and alternative strategies that borrowers can explore.

By consulting with Licensed Insolvency Trustees, individuals can gain valuable insights and guidance tailored to their specific circumstances, enabling them to make informed decisions and pursue the most appropriate debt relief solution.

Ultimately, by proactively addressing car loan obligations and exploring all available options, individuals can pave the way towards financial recovery and a more secure future.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.