Disadvantages of Consumer Proposals

Dissecting the Disadvantages of Consumer Proposals: Are They Really That Bad?

Consumer proposals are often seen as a lifeline for those grappling with an overwhelming sea of debt. However, like any financial tool, they come with their own set of drawbacks. In this article, we delve into the various disadvantages of consumer proposals, attempting to answer the question: Are they really that bad?

Understanding Consumer Proposals

Before we dive into the disadvantages, it’s crucial to understand what a consumer proposal entails. A consumer proposal is a legally binding agreement between a debtor and their unsecured creditors, facilitated by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT). This mechanism allows debtors to negotiate a payment plan, often reducing the total amount of debt and extending the repayment period.

Disadvantages of Consumer Proposals: A Deep Dive

While consumer proposals can provide substantial relief for debt-laden individuals, they aren’t without their cons. Here are some key disadvantages of consumer proposals:

Impact on Credit Score

The most apparent disadvantage of a consumer proposal is the adverse effect it has on your credit score. When you file a consumer proposal, it is recorded on your credit report and remains there for a maximum of six years from the date of filing. This can make obtaining further credit, such as loans or credit cards, challenging.

Surrendering Credit Cards

Once you enter a consumer proposal, you are required to surrender all your credit cards, and any lines of credit you have will be cancelled. This can make managing your finances more difficult, especially if you rely on credit for essential expenses.

Inability to Handle Secured Debt

A significant drawback of consumer proposals is that they can only handle unsecured debts. Secured debts, such as mortgages or car loans, are not included in consumer proposals. Therefore, if you have substantial secured debt, a consumer proposal may not provide the comprehensive debt relief you need.

Risk of Rejection by Creditors

Another disadvantage of consumer proposals is that your creditors may reject your proposal. Creditors have the right to vote on your proposal, and if they believe they could recover more of their debt through other means, they may reject it.

Debt Limit

Consumer proposals also come with a debt limit. If your total debt exceeds $250,000 (excluding your primary residence mortgage), you cannot file a consumer proposal. Instead, you would have to look into filing a Division I proposal which carries its own set of risks and complications.

Influence of Large Creditors

If you owe a significant amount to a single creditor, they could potentially influence the terms of your proposal. Because creditors’ votes are weighted according to the amount of debt you owe them, a large creditor could demand a higher payout percentage, potentially making your proposal more expensive.

Certain Debts Are Exempt

Not all unsecured debts can be included in a consumer proposal. Debts due to fraud, child support or alimony payments, court fines, and student loans (if you’ve been out of school for less than seven years) cannot be discharged through a consumer proposal.

Risk of Annulment

If you miss three months’ payments, your consumer proposal can be annulled. This means that your original debt is reinstated, and you lose the protection from creditors that the proposal provided.

Weighing the Disadvantages of Consumer Proposals

Though the disadvantages of consumer proposals may seem daunting, it’s important to remember that they also offer numerous benefits. They can significantly reduce your debt, provide protection from creditors, and allow you to keep your assets.

When deciding whether a consumer proposal is the right path for you, it’s crucial to weigh these disadvantages against the potential benefits. Speak with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee to better understand your options and make an informed decision.

The Silver Lining: Rebuilding Credit After a Consumer Proposal

While a consumer proposal will undoubtedly impact your credit score, it’s not the end of the road. You can start rebuilding your credit as soon as your proposal is complete. This can be achieved through responsible credit use, timely payments, and maintaining a low debt-to-income ratio.

Concluding Thoughts

The disadvantages of consumer proposals certainly exist, but they should be viewed in the context of your unique financial situation. For many, the benefits of filing a consumer proposal far outweigh the drawbacks. Consultation with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee can provide valuable guidance in navigating this decision, ensuring you choose the best path forward to financial stability.

Remember, financial struggles are a part of life, and tools like consumer proposals exist to help you regain control. Don’t let the disadvantages of consumer proposals deter you from seeking the relief you need. With the right plan and guidance, you can overcome your financial challenges and embark on a path to a debt-free future.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.