Is Being Debt-Free Good For Your Credit Report?

Is Zero Debt Beneficial for Your Credit Report?

Many individuals harbor the misconception that maintaining a nominal level of debt positively influences their credit report. Contrarily, they presume that complete freedom from debt can harm their credit score. This article delves into the complexities of these notions to provide you with a comprehensive understanding of credit scoring and reporting. We will also debunk prevalent myths about credit scores and discuss the impact of being debt-free on your credit report.

Understanding the Credit Score

Credit scores, assigned by major credit reporting agencies such as TransUnion and Equifax Canada, constitute a numerical representation of your credit risk. The score ranges from 300, indicating a poor credit risk, to 850 or 900, denoting excellent credit risk. Essentially, it predicts your likelihood of repaying your debt.

For instance, an Equifax score of 700 suggests that roughly 82% of individuals with this score are expected to repay their debt. Unlike your credit report which provides a more detailed account of your credit history, including payment history and credit utilization rate, a credit score simplifies this information into one number for easy reference by lenders.

Your credit score typically fluctuates month-to-month, influenced by the information reported to each agency by your creditors. The extent and frequency of these changes depend on how you manage and use your available credit.

Factoring Your Credit Score

The calculation of your credit score takes into account several factors, each with a particular weightage:


Payment History (35%):
This refers to your track record of making timely and full payments. It also considers missed payments and any payment arrangements.

Credit Utilization (30%):
This is the percentage of your total available credit that you’re using at any point.

Credit History Length (15%):
This measures the duration for which you’ve maintained your oldest credit account.

Credit Applications Frequency (10%):
This counts the number of hard inquiries, such as applications for new credit or credit limit increases, on your credit report.

Credit Types (10%):
This considers whether you’re using a variety of credit facilities such as credit cards, mortgages, car loans, and utilities accounts.

As evident from this breakdown, your credit score is determined not just by your credit behavior and payment history but also by how much of your available credit you utilize. To enhance your score, you should ideally use less than 50% of your credit limit on revolving credit lines like credit cards and lines of credit. Keeping it below 30% is even more beneficial.

For instance, if your credit card has a $1,000 limit, avoid using more than $300 before paying it off in full. Higher utilization indicates a higher risk of missed or default payments, especially if your income gets affected.

Evaluating Credit Scores in Canada

Equifax Canada defines credit score ranges as follows:

Credit Score / Credit Quality
300-559 / Poor
560-659 / Fair
660-724 / Good
725-759 / Very good
>760 / Excellent

TransUnion Canada follows a slightly different classification:

Credit Score / Credit Quality
300-692 / Poor
693-742 / Fair
743-789 / Good
790-832 / Very good
>833 / Excellent

According to Equifax data, over half of all Canadians have a credit score above 760, with about a third scoring under 559.

Debunking Credit Score Myths

Regrettably, several misconceptions about credit scores lead people to adopt ineffective or even detrimental strategies to improve their credit situation. Let’s dispel these misconceptions:


Income or job does not influence your credit score:
While lenders may consider these factors during their credit assessment process, they do not factor into the credit score calculation.

Spouses rarely have identical credit scores:
Even if all your debts are jointly held, there will likely be minor differences due to the factors outlined above.

Post-divorce, your score isn’t necessarily affected by your ex:
As long as one of you continues to service your joint debts, the other’s financial mishaps won’t impact you. However, you must ensure your name is removed from joint debts with the lender’s approval. A divorce agreement or court order does not prevent a creditor from pursuing both parties for the joint debt if they haven’t agreed to release you.

Credit scores aren’t necessarily free:
While credit bureaus are required to provide a free annual copy of your credit report, they are not obligated to include a credit score. Be cautious of third-party credit score providers as they may share your information with external parties.

You have multiple credit scores:
Equifax and TransUnion use slightly different calculations, and not all creditors report to both agencies. Therefore, some debts may appear on one report and not the other.

Filing for Bankruptcy or a Consumer Proposal does not permanently ruin your credit:
A record of a first-time filing remains on your credit report for 6-7 years, depending on your province. Any debt management solution that deviates from the contractual terms with lenders will impact your credit report, but this impact is temporary, and such programs include education on budgeting and goal-setting.

Being debt-free does not automatically result in a perfect credit score:
Your credit utilization accounts for less than a third of your total score.

The Impact of Zero Debt on Your Credit Score

It’s crucial to differentiate between being debt-free and being a responsible credit user. If your version of being debt-free involves avoiding loans, credit cards, and lines of credit, it’s unlikely to yield a high credit score due to the lack of sufficient data for scoring. Closing your credit accounts or leaving them inactive can exacerbate this issue.

However, it’s both possible and advisable to use your credit accounts responsibly without carrying any outstanding debt month-to-month. Remember, your score depends on your credit behavior and payment history, so maintaining at least one active account is necessary for demonstrating your debt management skills.

For instance, using one credit card for regular, budgeted purchases (like groceries), not exceeding 30% of your credit limit, and paying the balance in full by the due date will reflect positively on your credit behavior.

A Balanced Approach

While it’s easy to obsess over your credit score, striving for perfection isn’t necessarily advisable. A good credit score can certainly open up more borrowing opportunities and better interest rates. But the emphasis should be on ‘good,’ as defined by the credit reporting agencies – higher than 660 for Equifax and 743 for TransUnion.

Key criteria such as low credit utilization and a responsible payment history are indeed beneficial for your overall financial health. If you focus on these, coupled with careful management of your money, budget, and debt, your credit score should naturally improve.

It’s arguably more important to check your credit reports at least once annually for accuracy and report any discrepancies to the credit bureaus and your lenders promptly. In conclusion, it’s clear that being debt-free doesn’t necessarily harm your credit report if you manage your available credit wisely.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.