Once you’ve start a Consumer Proposal can you add another debt?

Once you've start a Consumer Proposal can you add another debt

Navigating the Complexities of Consumer Proposals: Can Additional Debts Be Accommodated?

When facing overwhelming financial burdens, a Consumer Proposal can offer a lifeline, providing a structured path to debt relief. However, unexpected circumstances may arise, leading to the question: “Once you’ve initiated a Consumer Proposal, can you add another debt?” This inquiry touches upon the intricate dynamics of debt management and the legal framework surrounding Consumer Proposals.

Understanding Consumer Proposals: A Comprehensive Overview

A Consumer Proposal is a legally binding agreement between an individual and their creditors, facilitated by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. This arrangement allows the debtor to consolidate and restructure their unsecured debts, offering a manageable repayment plan over a specified period, typically ranging from three to five years.

Key Benefits of a Consumer Proposal

  • Debt Consolidation: Multiple unsecured debts are combined into a single, streamlined payment plan, simplifying the repayment process.
  • Interest Relief: Interest charges on outstanding debts are effectively frozen, preventing further accumulation and providing breathing room.
  • Creditor Protection: Once the proposal is accepted, creditors are legally bound to its terms, shielding the debtor from garnishments, collections, or legal actions.
  • Asset Preservation: Unlike bankruptcy, a Consumer Proposal allows the debtor to retain valuable assets, such as their home or vehicle.

Eligibility Criteria for a Consumer Proposal

To qualify for a Consumer Proposal, an individual must meet specific criteria, including:

  • Residing in Canada
  • Having total debts below the prescribed limit (currently $250,000, excluding mortgage debt)
  • Possessing a regular income source or the ability to make periodic payments

The Dynamics of Adding Debts to an Existing Consumer Proposal

While a Consumer Proposal offers a structured solution for managing existing debts, unforeseen circumstances may lead to the accumulation of additional liabilities during the repayment period. In such cases, the question arises: Can these new debts be incorporated into the existing proposal?

Factors Influencing the Addition of New Debts

Several factors influence the ability to add new debts to an ongoing Consumer Proposal, including:

  1. Timing: The stage at which the new debt is incurred during the proposal period can impact the feasibility of incorporating it.
  2. Debt Type: The nature of the debt, whether secured or unsecured, plays a crucial role in determining its eligibility for inclusion.
  3. Creditor Consent: Modifying an existing proposal requires the consent of creditors, who may or may not agree to the proposed changes.
  4. Financial Capacity: The debtor’s ability to accommodate additional payments within the existing repayment plan is a critical consideration.

Exploring the Potential Scenarios

When faced with the need to address new debts during an active Consumer Proposal, various scenarios may unfold:

Scenario 1: Adding Unsecured Debts Early in the Proposal Period

If the new unsecured debt is incurred relatively early in the proposal period, it may be feasible to amend the existing agreement to include the additional liability. This process typically involves:

  1. Notifying the Licensed Insolvency Trustee of the new debt.
  2. Seeking creditor approval for the proposed modification.
  3. Adjusting the repayment plan to accommodate the increased debt burden.

Scenario 2: Adding Secured Debts or Debts Incurred Later in the Proposal

In cases where the new debt is secured or arises later in the proposal period, the process becomes more complex. Creditors may be less inclined to approve modifications, as it could potentially impact their recovery prospects. In such situations, alternative strategies may be explored, such as:

  1. Maintaining the existing proposal and addressing the new debt separately through alternative means (e.g., negotiating payment arrangements directly with the creditor).
  2. Considering the option of terminating the current proposal and exploring other debt relief solutions, such as bankruptcy or a new Consumer Proposal that encompasses all outstanding liabilities.

Scenario 3: Inability to Accommodate Additional Debts

If the debtor’s financial circumstances have significantly changed, making it impossible to accommodate additional payments within the existing repayment plan, creditors may refuse to amend the proposal. In this case, the debtor may need to explore alternative debt relief options or seek professional guidance from their Licensed Insolvency Trustee.

Navigating the Process: Steps and Considerations

When faced with the need to add new debts to an existing Consumer Proposal, it is crucial to follow a structured approach and seek professional guidance. Here are some key steps and considerations:

  1. Consult with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee: Seek advice from the Trustee overseeing your proposal to understand the feasibility of incorporating the new debt and the potential implications.
  2. Gather Comprehensive Financial Information: Provide detailed documentation regarding the new debt, including its nature, amount, and any relevant supporting documents.
  3. Assess Financial Capacity: Carefully evaluate your current financial situation, income, and expenses to determine your ability to accommodate additional payments within the existing repayment plan.
  4. Communicate with Creditors: If deemed feasible, the Trustee will initiate discussions with creditors, seeking their approval for the proposed modification.
  5. Negotiate Terms and Conditions: If creditors agree, work with the Trustee to negotiate the revised terms and conditions, including any adjustments to the repayment plan or duration.
  6. Execute the Modified Agreement: Once approved, the modified Consumer Proposal will be formalized, and the new repayment terms will take effect.

Seeking Professional Guidance: The Importance of Expert Advice

Navigating the complexities of Consumer Proposals and the potential addition of new debts can be challenging. It is crucial to seek professional guidance from Licensed Insolvency Trustees, who possess the expertise and legal knowledge to provide tailored advice based on your unique circumstances.

These professionals can help you:

  1. Understand Your Options: Evaluate the feasibility of adding new debts to your existing proposal and explore alternative debt relief strategies if necessary.
  2. Facilitate Creditor Negotiations: Leverage their experience and established relationships with creditors to negotiate favorable terms and increase the likelihood of approval for modifications.
  3. Ensure Compliance: Ensure that all legal requirements and procedures are followed correctly, minimizing the risk of complications or potential legal issues.
  4. Develop a Comprehensive Plan: Develop a comprehensive financial plan that addresses both your existing debts and any new liabilities, ensuring long-term financial stability.

By seeking professional guidance, you can navigate the complexities of Consumer Proposals with confidence, making informed decisions that align with your financial goals and circumstances.


Adding new debts to an existing Consumer Proposal is a complex process that requires careful consideration and adherence to legal procedures. While it may be possible in certain circumstances, the feasibility depends on various factors, including the timing of the new debt, its nature, creditor consent, and the debtor’s financial capacity.

By seeking professional guidance from Licensed Insolvency Trustees and maintaining open communication with creditors, individuals can explore their options and make informed decisions that align with their financial goals. Ultimately, the ability to add new debts to a Consumer Proposal is contingent upon a thorough assessment of individual circumstances and the willingness of all parties involved to negotiate and modify the existing agreement.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.