When to Consider a Consumer Proposal vs Debt Consolidation

Exploring Debt Solutions: Consumer Proposal versus Debt Consolidation

When financial distress strikes, it’s often challenging to determine the right course to navigate through the stormy seas of debt. One needs to weigh the options and decide when to consider a consumer proposal vs debt consolidation. This article explores these two debt relief strategies, helping you to understand their pros, cons, and implications.

Understanding the Concept of a Consumer Proposal

A consumer proposal is a legal agreement facilitated by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), offering structured repayments and partial debt forgiveness. It’s an effective way to manage unsecured debts, but it doesn’t apply to secured debts like your mortgage or car loan.

The Process of Consumer Proposal

When you approach an LIT, they assess your income, assets, liabilities, and expenses to determine a feasible amount you can pay towards your debt. The LIT drafts a consumer proposal outlining your monthly payments and the duration of repayments, which could extend up to five years. The total repayment under the proposal is invariably less than your original debt.

After you fulfill your proposal’s terms, attending two mandatory debt counselling sessions, the remaining debt is written off. The LIT presents this proposal to your creditors, and if they agree, all interest charges cease, collection calls stop, wage garnishments are lifted, and you retain your assets.

A consumer proposal simplifies your debt repayment process by consolidating your payments into one monthly payment to the LIT.

Debt Consolidation: Is it the Same as a Consumer Proposal?

While debt consolidation shares some similarities with a consumer proposal, there are significant differences. A financial institution, such as a bank, provides a debt consolidation loan, which pays off all your existing debts, replacing them with a single loan of equivalent value.

Like a consumer proposal, debt consolidation simplifies your repayments into one monthly payment. However, with a debt consolidation loan, you’re liable to repay the entire debt plus interest, which often totals more than your original debt. Furthermore, a debt consolidation loan allows you to acquire more debt while you’re still repaying your loan, which could potentially lead to a greater debt burden.

On the upside, a debt consolidation loan doesn’t negatively impact your credit score and can actually boost it if you make regular timely payments.

Credit Score Implications of a Consumer Proposal

Since a consumer proposal involves debt forgiveness (you won’t repay the full amount to your creditors), it remains on your credit report for six years, or three years from when you pay it off. This can affect your ability to secure loans and the interest rate you’re offered.

Despite this, a consumer proposal offers a fresh start by eradicating your existing debt and enabling you to begin rebuilding your credit.

Alternative Debt Relief Strategies

Other popular debt relief options are bankruptcy, debt settlement, and debt management. They bear some similarities to both consumer proposals and debt consolidation, but each has its unique features.

Debt Management Plan versus Consumer Proposal

A debt management plan involves a voluntary agreement to repay your debt in full, facilitated by a credit counsellor. Unlike a consumer proposal, it provides less legal protection and doesn’t prevent wage garnishing or stop creditors from contacting you.

Debt Settlement or Consumer Proposal: Which is Better?

A debt settlement involves negotiating with each of your creditors individually to eliminate your debt through a single payment or plan. In contrast, a consumer proposal, debt consolidation, and debt management plan allow you to address multiple creditors simultaneously.

Debt settlement companies are often private entities, and you should exercise caution when engaging their services.

Be aware that a debt settlement usually involves a one-off lump sum payment, which can be more challenging than a structured payment plan designed by a credit counsellor or LIT.

You are Not Alone in Debt

Debt can be an overwhelming and isolating experience, but you don’t have to tackle it alone. A consultation with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee is free, and they can guide you in choosing the best debt relief option for your unique circumstances.

For further assistance, contact an LIT today for a no-cost consultation.

Have Debt-related Queries?

Schedule a free consultation today.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.