Why Budgeting is a Bad Idea

Rethinking Financial Management

Many of us start the year with the resolution to manage our finances better, often by creating a budget. However, Why Budgeting is a Bad Idea might surprise you.

Breaking Down the Budgeting Myth

Like dieting, budgeting can be a difficult and time-consuming process that often yields little results. It demands a high level of discipline and meticulousness in tracking every single expenditure, which can be quite challenging.

The reality is, not everyone can maintain such a regime. So, if the traditional budgeting method fails for most, what’s the alternative?

The Simplicity of Pay-as-you-Earn

The secret to effective financial management lies not in budgeting, but in aligning your bill payments with your pay cycle.

This means, if you receive your salary bi-weekly, you should aim to pay your bills every two weeks as well. This simple yet effective method can help you stay on top of your finances without the hassle of maintaining spreadsheets or tracking every penny spent.

Case in Point: Utility Bills

Consider a typical utility bill like electricity. Let’s say the bill is due on the 30th of every month and you get paid twice a month, on the 13th and 27th.

Instead of using a portion of your second paycheck to pay the entire bill, divide the bill into two equal parts. Use online banking to schedule a payment every payday. This way, by the 30th, your bill is fully paid without straining your finances.

The Advantage of Extra Paychecks

If you adopt this pay-as-you-earn system, there might be instances where you get an extra paycheck in a month. For example, if you get paid bi-weekly, some months will have three paydays. This is an excellent opportunity to get ahead of your bills.

The Benefits of Pay-as-you-Earn

This simple change from traditional budgeting to a pay-as-you-earn system can have several benefits:

  • Reduced Worry: With automatic bill payments aligned with your payday, you exactly know how much money you have left to spend for the week.
  • No Budgeting Hassles: Since your bills are paid as soon as you receive your paycheck, you don’t have to budget for them in the coming weeks.
  • Always Ahead on Bills: In months with an extra paycheck, you can make an additional payment towards your bills. This helps you stay ahead and provides a cushion in case you need to skip a payment in the future.

Handling Non-weekly Bills

Paying weekly works well for bills that can be paid online. But what about expenses like rent or annual insurance premiums that can’t be divided into weekly payments?


Budgeting can be an arduous task that might not yield the desired results. If you find budgeting hard to stick to, consider the pay-as-you-earn method. It simplifies financial management and aligns your expenses with your income, making it easier to stay on top of your bills.

If you’re struggling with debt or finding it hard to make ends meet, exploring debt relief options can be a good start. Remember, the goal is not just to manage your finances better, but to build a secure financial future.

Remember, when it comes to personal finance, one size does not fit all. Find what works best for you and stick to it. After all, the best financial plan is the one you can follow consistently.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.