Will CRA Accept my Consumer Proposal?

Will CRA Accept my Consumer Proposal

Navigating the Complexities: Will the Canada Revenue Agency Accept Your Consumer Proposal?

When financial burdens become overwhelming, a Consumer Proposal can offer a lifeline, providing a structured path to debt relief. However, for many Canadians grappling with tax debts, a crucial question arises: “Will the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) accept my Consumer Proposal?” This article delves into the nuances of this process, shedding light on the CRA’s approach and offering strategies to enhance the chances of proposal acceptance.

Understanding the CRA’s Role in Debt Management

The Canada Revenue Agency is a federal institution entrusted with administering tax laws and overseeing various economic benefit programs across the nation. While its primary function revolves around tax collection and compliance, the CRA also plays a pivotal role in debt management and resolution.

Contrary to popular belief, the CRA is not a monolithic entity but rather a multifaceted organization comprising numerous departments and divisions, each with distinct responsibilities and protocols. This intricate structure underscores the importance of comprehending the CRA’s operations, particularly when navigating financial challenges or seeking debt relief solutions.

The CRA’s Stance on Tax Debts

The CRA’s stance on tax debts is unequivocal: taxpayers are expected to fulfill their obligations promptly and in their entirety. If individuals find themselves unable to meet these commitments, the agency anticipates proactive measures to resolve the situation expeditiously.

In cases where tax debts become insurmountable, the CRA views a Consumer Proposal as a viable last resort, provided that the proposed terms represent the best possible return for the government. This approach aligns with the agency’s mission to safeguard the integrity of Canada’s tax system while acknowledging the financial challenges faced by some taxpayers.

Demystifying the Consumer Proposal Process

A Consumer Proposal is a legally binding agreement facilitated by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), allowing individuals to repay a portion of their debts over an extended period, typically up to five years. This arrangement offers several advantages, including the ability to retain assets, halt wage garnishments, and cease collection efforts by creditors.

However, it’s crucial to recognize that a Consumer Proposal can impact an individual’s credit rating and potentially hinder future borrowing opportunities. Therefore, careful consideration and professional guidance are paramount before embarking on this path.

The Role of the Licensed Insolvency Trustee

Licensed Insolvency Trustees play a pivotal role in the Consumer Proposal process, acting as intermediaries between debtors and their creditors, including the CRA. These professionals work closely with individuals to develop realistic and manageable repayment plans that reflect their financial capabilities.

Once a proposal is formulated, the trustee presents it to the creditors for consideration. If accepted, the trustee oversees the administration of the repayment plan, ensuring timely payments and fair treatment of all parties involved.

Factors Influencing the CRA’s Decision

When evaluating a Consumer Proposal, the CRA considers a range of factors to determine its viability and potential acceptance. These considerations include:

  1. Amount of Tax Debt Owed: The CRA closely examines the total amount of tax debt owed, assessing its significance and the proposed repayment terms.
  2. Ability to Repay: The agency scrutinizes the individual’s income, expenses, assets, and overall financial situation to gauge their capacity to fulfill the proposed repayment obligations.
  3. Compliance History: Past adherence to tax laws and obligations, including timely filing of returns, plays a crucial role in the CRA’s assessment.
  4. Comparison to Bankruptcy: The CRA evaluates whether the proposed repayment terms offer a better return than what could be expected through personal bankruptcy, which may be an alternative option if the proposal is rejected.
  5. Future Tax Compliance: The CRA seeks assurances that the individual will remain compliant with tax obligations during and after the Consumer Proposal period, avoiding the accumulation of additional tax debts.

By carefully weighing these factors, the CRA aims to strike a balance between providing debt relief opportunities and protecting the integrity of Canada’s tax system.

Strategies to Enhance Proposal Acceptance

While the CRA’s decision-making process is multifaceted, there are several strategies individuals can employ to increase the likelihood of their Consumer Proposal being accepted:

  1. Ensure Tax Returns are Current: Before filing a proposal, it is imperative to ensure that all outstanding tax returns are filed and up-to-date. The CRA is less likely to consider a proposal if there are outstanding tax filings.
  2. Propose a Reasonable Repayment Plan: A realistic and manageable repayment plan that offers a fair return to creditors, including the CRA, significantly enhances the chances of acceptance.
  3. Demonstrate Financial Transparency: Providing accurate and transparent information about income, expenses, and assets can help build trust and credibility with the CRA.
  4. Seek Professional Guidance: Consulting with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee or a tax professional can provide valuable insights into the CRA’s expectations and help navigate the proposal process effectively.
  5. Address Compliance Concerns: If the CRA has concerns about future tax compliance, individuals can proactively address these concerns by committing to timely filing and payment of taxes during the proposal period.

By implementing these strategies, individuals can increase their chances of having their Consumer Proposal accepted by the CRA, paving the way for a fresh financial start.

Potential Outcomes and Alternatives

If the CRA rejects a Consumer Proposal, individuals may face limited options, with personal bankruptcy being a potential consequence. Bankruptcy can result in the loss of assets and significant long-term impacts on credit ratings.

However, it’s important to note that if other creditors holding a majority of the debt value (over 50%) vote in favor of the proposal, the CRA may be obligated to accept it, even if they initially rejected it.

In cases where the CRA holds the majority of the debt and rejects the proposal, individuals may have the opportunity to revise and resubmit the proposal or explore alternative debt management strategies, such as negotiating payment plans or seeking debt relief through other means.

Life After a Successful Consumer Proposal

Completing a Consumer Proposal successfully can provide a fresh start and a pathway to financial stability. Upon fulfilling the repayment obligations outlined in the proposal, individuals are legally released from the debts included, including tax debts owed to the CRA.

While the process may initially impact credit ratings, individuals can gradually rebuild their creditworthiness by adopting responsible financial practices and adhering to future tax obligations. With perseverance and discipline, a Consumer Proposal can serve as a stepping stone towards a brighter financial future.

Seeking Professional Guidance

Navigating the complexities of a Consumer Proposal, especially when tax debts are involved, can be daunting. However, individuals do not have to embark on this journey alone. Seeking professional guidance from Licensed Insolvency Trustees and tax professionals can provide invaluable insights, support, and guidance throughout the process.

These experts can assess individual circumstances, advise on the suitability of a Consumer Proposal, and represent clients’ interests effectively during negotiations with creditors, including the CRA. Their expertise can significantly increase the chances of a successful outcome and pave the way for a sustainable financial recovery.


The decision of whether the Canada Revenue Agency will accept a Consumer Proposal is a complex and multifaceted process. While the CRA’s primary objective is to ensure tax compliance and protect the integrity of the tax system, it also recognizes the need for debt relief solutions in certain circumstances.

By understanding the CRA’s approach, employing strategic tactics, and seeking professional guidance, individuals can navigate the Consumer Proposal process with greater confidence and increase their chances of achieving a favorable outcome.

Ultimately, a successful Consumer Proposal can provide a fresh start, alleviate the burden of overwhelming debt, and pave the way for a brighter financial future. With determination and the right support, Canadians can overcome financial challenges and regain control of their financial well-being.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.