Second Mortgage Home Equity Loan or Interest-Free Consumer Proposal?

A Consumer Proposal Is Interest Free, Why You Should Explore It

Owning a home brings with it the potential for significant equity, especially in today’s booming real estate market. However, for many homeowners, high-interest unsecured debt can complicate financial stability. Although you may possess equity in your property, you might still face insolvency, struggling to meet your financial obligations as they come due. This dynamic can lead homeowners to explore various debt consolidation strategies, such as leveraging their home equity or considering a 100% consumer proposal. In this article, we’ll delve into these options, breaking down their intricacies, pros, and cons to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Home Equity Debt Consolidation

Home equity debt consolidation essentially allows homeowners to leverage their property value to pay off their debts. There are four primary ways to achieve this:


Refinancing: This involves negotiating a new mortgage with your current lender, incorporating your consumer debt into the mortgage.

Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC): A secured credit line that lets you draw from a fixed credit limit to pay off unsecured debt.

Second Mortgage Home Equity Loan: A personal loan secured against your home and structured similarly to a mortgage, providing a lump sum to pay off outstanding debts.

Consumer Proposal: A repayment plan proposed to creditors, specifically for Canadians unable to repay their debts.


Let’s delve into the specifics of each option, exploring their benefits and potential drawbacks.

Refinancing Your Mortgage

Refinancing allows homeowners to replace their existing mortgage with a new one, usually at a higher principal balance to cover consumer debts. The maximum refinancing amount is typically 80% of your home’s appraised value. The new mortgage terms provide a lump sum that you can use to pay off your credit card debt. There’s the potential to save money if interest rates have dropped since your last mortgage agreement, but you might face penalties for breaking your existing contract early.

Pros and Cons of Refinancing

Despite offering the advantage of a single monthly payment, refinancing can also lead to a higher mortgage payment due to the increased principal balance. However, this can be counterbalanced by the elimination of separate credit card payments. The key is to ensure that refinancing improves your cash flow, not worsen it.

Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC)

A HELOC is a standalone line of credit secured against your home’s equity, providing a revolving line of credit that you can borrow from and repay as needed. The maximum loan-to-value ratio for a HELOC is 65% of your home’s value.

Pros and Cons of HELOCs

HELOCs offer the flexibility of borrowing and repaying as required, with the credit limit remaining intact as long as you meet your minimum payments. However, they charge variable interest rates, which can be a downside if you have a poor credit score.

Second Mortgage Home Equity Loan

If you’re unable to refinance with your current lender, a second mortgage home equity loan could be a viable option. You can borrow up to 90% of your home’s market value, helping you consolidate your debts into a single payment.

Pros and Cons of Second Mortgage

The advantage of a second mortgage is the absence of prepayment penalties. However, interest rates on second mortgages are usually higher, which can offset these savings.

Qualifying for a Home Equity Loan

To be eligible for a home equity loan, you must meet certain lender qualifications:


  • The loan-to-value ratio should not exceed 80% for a first mortgage, 65% for a HELOC, and 90% for a second or private mortgage.
  • Your debt service ratios must fall within allowable limits, with most lenders requiring that your housing costs plus other debt payments do not exceed 43% of your gross income.
  • You must pass the mortgage stress test to demonstrate that you can afford the payments even if interest rates rise.
  • A reasonably good credit score is required, with lower scores significantly limiting your options and leading to higher interest rates.


Risks of Second-tier Lenders

If you’re unable to access your equity through a traditional mortgage lender, you might consider second-tier mortgage lenders. However, these lenders can be significantly more expensive, with the monthly payment potentially remaining too high to improve your cash flow situation. Defaulting on a second mortgage can further damage your credit score and potentially risk foreclosure.

Decoding 100% Consumer Proposal

A consumer proposal is a repayment plan negotiated with your creditors. It’s not a loan, but rather a way to repay all your debts over a period of up to five years. This option can be beneficial if you have sufficient equity in your home to cover all your debts but can’t access this equity cost-effectively.

Advantages of Consumer Proposals

Consumer proposals offer several benefits:


  • You retain ownership of your home.
  • Payments are interest-free.
  • Debt is eliminated in five years.
  • It can be significantly less expensive in the long run.


However, if you can’t afford the payments under a consumer proposal, it’s possible to extend the term through a Division I proposal.


The best choice between a second mortgage home equity loan or an interest-free consumer proposal depends on your unique financial situation. If your house is worth more than you owe and you have a good payment history with your mortgage company, then consolidating your debt using your home equity at a reasonable cost might be the best option. However, if the interest rate is too high or you don’t qualify, a consumer proposal could be a more viable solution. Always consider all your options and consult with a financial advisor or a Licensed Insolvency Trustee for a more detailed cost comparison.

Find Your Personal Debt Relief Solution

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are here to help. Get a free assessment of your options.

Discuss options to get out of debt with a trained & licensed debt relief professional.